Stellians in Central City

This place was awesome. We had to wait 20 minutes for a table, but it was worth it. We wanted to be sure to leave room for one of their fabulous shakes, so we got an order of Mozzi bread and a meatball grinder to share. The bread was so good, all hot and buttery with garlic and cheese. We only ate half of the bread and the fries that came with the grinder and took the rest home for supper. The shake didn’t disappoint. Their shakes are pricey, but worth the splurge.

its okay, it is the home of the 8lb pizza and that is what we ordered after about 45 minutes it got to our table and it was floating in liquid, honestly the crust is probably 4 lbs not the best. If I go back I'll try something else instead of the pizza. The wait staff was really nice.

A must stop and gorge yourself on some the best pizza outside of Chicago. The breadsticks are in a class of their own. Freak shakes are a worth it heart attack risk.

Fantastic place to eat. The milkshakes are great

The fried pepperoncinis were awesome.

The pizza is great! The shakes are delicious but over priced. Also the quality of the sandwiches are just mediocre especially for the price. So if you go, stick to the pizza and some sodas.

Really nice place and friendly staff! Food was really good especially the appetizers!!

Worst pizza I’ve ever eaten. Drive over an hour, waited about 45 minutes to get the 8lb pizza & couldn’t eat 1 piece. Not because it was filling, it was soaked in some sort of liquid. It was so soggy that the toppings fell off the water drenched crust. We also tried the spinach dip & half way through we found some sort of ground meat in our chips!! Was never asked how was or if we liked it. $40’ down the drain. Will never go back.

Pizza only was well priced. We had the meaty. It was very meaty and fine quality.

A must try! We really enjoyed the pizza and it is definitely a better quality pie than the chain stores. Their freak shakes are a sight to see and definitely worth the try. I'm sure you won't go home hungry.

The food was AMAZING! Our server was very kind and attentive. It was worth the 1.45 hour drive!

Waitress was the one of the best that we have ever had. Food was hot and delicious. We would definitely go again and recommend to others. They were very diligent to adhere to all the covid guildlines while we were there. Come very hungry.

Amazing pizza, food and service was great. Fresh ingredients! Will eat here again!

Service was excellent! Food was excellent! Atmosphere was great!

The service was good. I really had high hopes after reading all the reviews. Don’t get me wrong, the food is good it’s just nothing to write home about. The ingredients are high quality however some of the toppings for the pizza came from the freezer section. The stuffed jalapeño peppers were good, but again they were straight out of the freezer section. Also I was disappointed with the ranch dressing, again this wasn’t made in house. The restaurant has a nice feel and it’s kind of worn down which gives the perception of killer dive food, but it just doesn’t deliver.

Fantastic food!!! Out of this world proportions for awesome prices! Will definitely be back!! Better come hungry! The big pizza takes about 45 minutes to cook so better not be in a hurry.

I can not say enough good things about this place! Food was nothing short of AMAZING!! For appetizers we got 74 wings 1/2 sweet heat 1/2 Buffalo, 2 orders of mozzarella bread, 2 orders of fried raviolis, and a big basket of deep fried peperoncinis. Followed by the main course, an 8 lb pizza!!!! For dessert was beautifully mastered milk shakes. We feed 8 people and our bill was only $158.00 for ALL OF THAT FOOD! I was very impressed with not only the food, but our server was outstanding! Highly recommend this establishment, we'll be back. It was worth the 2 hour drive from Princeton, IN.

How did I not know this place existed? Highly highly recommemd if you are a Chicago style pizza lover. Was totally thrilled with our food. It was a tiny bit doughy and we sent it back to bake but that's a huge pizza, so that was not an issue for us. Already trying to figure when we can get back. Be prepared ... The Chicago pizza could take up to an hour to bake. I was grateful they told us that for future reference. Kudos kudos to a fantastic waitress SAYLOR. She took great care of us! ❤ (inside joke .. she definitely is not a loser 😂😂😂)

Took our boys for their birthday, loved everything we ordered and the waitress was great.

Super fun place!!!! Great for a group, a nice novelty restaurant. We shared the 8 pound pizza between 3 adults and 2 kids and had left overs. The milkshakes are super fun too!! The kids loved it so did adults. Its a win win!! Everyone was happy 😊

Was very surprised how great this hole in the wall pizza place is. Can't wait to go back and try the special. We didn't want to wait 45min they were busy. But being a pizza guy traveling all over the United States in a motorhome always had to try a pizza. And this comes in the top 10 sauce was very tasty, just wish there was fennel in there sausage

I came for the giant pizza and amazing shakes for Valentines day, and i left feeling like i got SO MUCH MORE!!!The 8lbs pizza is not just a monstrosity, but it is also DELICIOUS, and a GREAT price!!! Honestly, 4 people could share this one pizza and a couple of their stellar shakes and leave FULL for under $10 each with absolutely PREMIUM food.This restaurant is 1 hour away from me, and it just became out absolute #1 favorite restaurant!I knocked it down 1 star for the bathrooms which leave a bit to desire, so it went from 6/5 stars to 5/5 ;-)My wife and i cant wait to go back, and next time we will bring friends!

Good pizza, huge deep dish Chicago style. Service was a little slow but friendly. 45 minute wait time for the deep dish pizza but the thinner crust pizzas were being served quicker. Large and elaborate milkshakes.

I LOVED this place! First time customer and I was thoroughly impressed! The pizza was freaking amazing. I'm still eating on it a day later 😂. The shakes were to die for also! Y'all need to go down there one day! Take the family!

OMGosh, definitely the best pizza I've ever had!

The freak show milkshake is amazing. I got the strawberry cheesecake milk shake and it was the best milkshake ever. The fried pickles was good also.

Great place to eat! Will go many more times! Food was awesome and so was the staff